Work

Meaningful Consideration: Accountability in Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Review of NGO Submissions in the Post-Job Creation Law Era

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Research on public participation in environmental impact assessment (EIA) following the Job Creation Law has focused on restrictions during EIA preparation. The subsequent handling of suggestions, opinions, and responses submitted by environmental non-governmental organizations (NGOs) remains underexamined. This study examines NGO participation rights and the legal accountability of the Environmental Feasibility Assessment Team (EFAT) under Articles 29, 31, 35, and 45 of Government Regulation No. 22 of 2021 and proposes a framework for ensuring that NGO submissions receive meaningful consideration. The study uses a doctrinal legal method, applying statutory, conceptual, and historical approaches to primary and secondary legal materials collected through documentary research and examined through qualitative prescriptive analysis. The analysis finds that NGO participation rights are derivative and conditional, arising from their role as facilitators or representatives of directly affected communities. It identifies three accountability gaps: project proponents have no duty to explain how they handle submissions, the EFAT screens submissions using an undefined relevance criterion, and assessment minutes need not document how submissions were addressed. The EFAT’s accountability remains predominantly procedural, with substantive legal consequences yet to be established. The proposed framework requires relevant submissions to be formally recorded, examined on their merits, taken into account during assessment, and addressed through reasoned responses. It extends the doctrine of meaningful participation from legislative processes to environmental administrative decision-making and provides concrete proposals for regulatory policymakers and assessment bodies. Future empirical research could examine EFAT assessment minutes to establish how NGO submissions are handled in practice.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236266813
FWCI:
Cites: 20
Cited by:
Related to: 10