Work

Ricardo's Ceiling: Labor Facing AI, within One Country and then between Two. A Teaching Note on the Four Numbers of 1817

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This note is a numerical parable, not a forecast. An earlier note took up Ricardo's example (100, 120, 90, 80) by giving artificial intelligence the role of Portugal. That convention attributed purchases to AI, although nothing indicates that it has needs. The present note keeps the four numbers and changes the reading: AI is a tool owned by the inhabitants of a country. In a single country, humans and AI share out the goods according to their comparative advantage. The gain of workers is capped, at 27/20 for wine, while the income of the country grows without limit and the share of labor tends to zero. With several goods, each good has its own ceiling, equal to the ratio of the best relative cost of humans to the relative cost of that good. This ceiling rises if there is a refuge good in which AI is less efficient than humans, and it disappears if AI cannot produce that good. Between two countries of which only one adopts AI, the country that abstains gains from trade, but its gain has the same ceiling. The workers of both countries obtain the same bundle, and the whole gap between the countries comes from the income of AI. All calculations are carried out in exact fractions. This record contains two files: the English version and a French version of the same note ("Le plafond de Ricardo. Le travail face à l'IA, dans un pays puis entre deux pays. Une note pédagogique sur les quatre chiffres de 1817"). Declaration of generative AI use: the author used Claude (Claude Fable 5.2, Anthropic) to build the model, carry out the calculations, and draft the text, under his direction. The author raised the question, steered the construction of the example, gathered the sources, reviewed and verified the content, and takes full responsibility for it. Keywords: comparative advantage; Ricardo; artificial intelligence; labor share; AI adoption; gains from trade. JEL classification: F11, O33, A22, B12.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236268623
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10