STANDING: enforcement machinery for standing and floors — why declared rights decay without operative-layer guardians
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Standing for the harmed party is the instrument transition theory says must precede pricing — yet the implementation literature shows granted standing is frequently symbolic: ~40 freshwater systems hold legal rights, and reviews find victories "reduced to symbolic announcements" where guardianship lacks funding, autonomy, or powers; a 360+ decision apex-courts dataset finds 49% enhance vs 40% hinder. We read this through the carrier-layer model: standing without enforcement is the institutional masked-decay signature, and the documented success pattern (funded, distributed, autonomous guardianship with remedies) is verification attached to the operative layer — the same architecture agent studies measured. The paper delivers the enforcement instrument census and the escape-cost sequencing rule the literature lacks. Companion to the LESS/IS/MORE program (eleventh record).
Parent works: MORE: An Evolutionary, Regenerative and Life-Centred Economic Framework, LESS: The Revealed Objective of the Incumbent Economy, IS: How Objectives Switch — A Transition Science for Life-Centred Economics, TRIANGULATE: Trust-minimized MRV for AI normative audits — multimodal triangulation so the answer does not depend on trusting any single measurer, FORMATION: the dispositional layer at population scale — media, education, and narrative as control systems for what a population is built to want, ALIGNMENT: Do open-weight LLMs optimize LESS or MORE? A revealed-objective audit, SWITCHING: Objective switching inside agents — eight transition propositions instantiated at agent scale, and what the human parallel does and does not show, MANDATE: objective-bearing instructions at institutional and agent scale — the unclaimed slot between permission-mandates and pricing, Pushing toward MORE: measured levers for switching agent and institutional objectives, BELIEF: Do self-rewriting agents know what they optimize? Three candidate answers tested on the private-return/life-capacity axis
Author: Price, Thomas Ryan
Language: English
Topic: Environmental law and policy
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236269702
