SAE Propagation of Cultivation Paper 3: The Propagation of Cultivation: Breaking / SAE 涵育的传播 Paper 3: 涵育的传播:打断
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The previous paper read how a practice headed toward colonization passes downstream. This paper reads how it stops with one person: breaking. Breaking has two sides, both in the first person. The receiving side is not letting what lands on me occupy the place of my own judgment. The giving side is not colonizing others, whether by pouring in the same thing or its opposite. Merely having no occasion, pausing for a while, or switching to another way of managing people is not recorded as breaking on appearance alone. The two sides need not arrive together: what took hold in a person may still be there while he no longer pours it into the next person. Not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other. Their sources are read apart and do not exclude each other. The giving side is a choice a person makes when facing another person; declining to pass it on this time need not come from having been cultivated earlier. On the receiving side, where something has already taken hold, upstream writes that internal colonization cannot be broken from within alone; here conditions given by another person can be read. Either side may have conditions given by someone else, and on either side the step remains the person's own. Breaking is not, in itself, cultivation; structurally it is read as a step in the 15DD direction. That is a reading of one operation and certifies nothing about which layer the whole person is at. On the receiving side there is no criterion guaranteed to close the question of how one knows that such a place in oneself has been occupied; the way of looking back can be mistaken, and no one else makes the judgment. The paper uses one passage from Frederick Douglass's autobiography as historical material, reading his end only. It does not show that someone who has made such a break will go on to cultivate, does not say what kind of person someone is who has not, gives no method for breaking, and does not tell anyone what he ought to break. 上一篇读带殖民方向的做法怎样往下。这一篇读它怎样到一个人为止:打断。打断有两面,都是第一人称的。受的一面,是不让落到自己身上的占住自己判断的位置;给的一面,是自己不去殖民别人,照样灌是,反着灌也是。只是没有机会、暂时停下、或换了一种管法,不凭外观记作打断。 两面可以不同时到:落在身上的那一处还在,对下一个人已经不去灌。不去灌,不等于已经能承认。两面的来路分开读,不互相排除。给的一面是一个人面对另一个人时的一次选择;这一次不往下灌,不必先由前一段涵育接来。受的一面,已经占住的那一处,上游写内在殖民不能仅从内部打破;这里可以读到另一个人给的条件。哪一面都可以有别人给的条件,哪一面的那一步都仍是他自己的。 打断本身还不是涵育,结构上读作朝 15DD 方向去的一步;这是一次运作上的读数,不认证整个人在哪一层。受的一面怎样知道那一处占住了自己,没有可保证闭合的判准;回看的办法可以看错,别人不替他判。 这一篇用道格拉斯自述里的一处作史料,只读他这一端。它不证明打断了的人就会去涵育,不证明没有打断的人是怎样的人,不给一个人怎样打断的办法,也不指认谁该打断什么。
Author: Qin, Han
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236270537
