Work

ALTERAÇÕES CLIMÁTICAS - Uma análise crítica da atribuição causal, das incertezas científicas e da política de descarbonização

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Earth’s climate has undergone profound changes throughout approximately 4.54 billion years of terrestrial history, long before human activity, in response to solar, orbital, tectonic, volcanic, oceanic and biogeochemical mechanisms. This study critically examines these drivers and the attribution of contemporary global warming, distinguishing direct instrumental observations, palaeoclimate reconstructions, physical-statistical inference and scenario-dependent projections. Human influence on the planetary radiation balance is supported by multiple independent lines of evidence; nevertheless, substantial uncertainties remain regarding climate sensitivity, cloud and aerosol feedbacks, regional variability and the future evolution of several categories of extreme events. The absence of complete scientific unanimity on particular mechanisms and parameters does not imply that the evidence for a predominant human contribution to recent global warming is absent. [1, 10, 17, 20–22] The study examines the indispensable role of the natural greenhouse effect in sustaining habitable conditions, and the importance of the ocean as the largest heat reservoir within the climate system, mediating heat uptake, circulation and climate variability. With regard to weather extremes, robust evidence for increases in extreme heat and heavy precipitation in many regions is distinguished from the lack of uniform global trends for several other hazards. Reported disaster counts and unadjusted economic losses are not treated as direct measures of physical hazard frequency. [2, 9, 11, 52–54] The economic assessment compares energy-transition and climate-transition investment in the European Union and Portugal with observed emissions reductions, consumption-based emission footprints, emissions embodied in imports and possible carbon leakage arising from industrial relocation. Observed territorial reductions do not, by themselves, establish the marginal effectiveness, full-system cost or economic proportionality of individual programmes. The considerable financial scale of decarbonisation also warrants scrutiny of lobbying, conflicts of interest and weaknesses in public financial oversight, without equating institutional risk with proven systematic corruption. The principal conclusion is that reducing anthropogenic climate forcing does not amount to comprehensive control of the climate system. Mitigation should therefore be appraised alongside adaptation, resilience, security of energy supply and transparent, counterfactual estimates of the full economic cost per tonne of greenhouse gases effectively avoided. The study calls for open scientific challenge and evidence-based, economically proportionate public policy. Keywords: climate attribution; natural variability; ocean heat content; greenhouse effect; weather extremes; CMIP6; carbon leakage; European Union; Portugal; system costs; decarbonisation; regulatory capture.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236271454
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10