Prescribing coefficients of invariant irreducible polynomials over finite fields: counterexamples, corrected formulas, and complete restoration
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: For a lower-triangular A in GL(2,q), G. Kapetanakis (J. Number Theory 180 (2017), 615–628, doi:10.1016/j.jnt.2017.05.003) studied which coefficients of the monic irreducible polynomials over F_q invariant under A are forced and which can be prescribed. This note shows that several statements of that paper are false or unproved: the coefficient formula of its Theorem 2.8 is wrong; its inequality (5) cannot hold for μ = 2 when q ≤ 64, so that every row of its Table 2 fails; Theorem 3.4(2) is false, the coefficient taking a single value instead of φ(r)(q−1)/r values; the diagonal case of Theorem 3.4 is misstated twice; and the proof of Theorem 3.4(3) does not control the constant term. Complete statements and proofs are then given. Counting directly over all admissible residue classes modulo X^(μ+1), without the von Mangoldt weights of the original argument, both existence statements are proved with no exceptional pairs at all: for one eigenvalue, every κ in F_q occurs whenever 2 ≤ μ ≤ n/2; for two eigenvalues, whenever 1 ≤ μ < n/2. The finitely many cases not reached by the bounds (5710 and 719 cases) are settled by explicit polynomials. The comparison is with the author's repository text of the paper dated 24 May 2017; the printed version was not compared and may differ. This record contains the note (LaTeX source and PDF), the verification program (Python, sympy), its log and machine-readable output (JSON), and the two figures. Source repository: https://github.com/Ruqing1963/kapetanakis-2017-jnt-audit
Author: Chen, Ruqing
Language: English
Subfield: Geometry and Topology
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236285272
