Calcite Saturation Index Methods for Pool Water: Comparison for Peer Review (Revision 6)
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Comparison of calcite saturation index methods used for swimming pool water, prepared for peer review. The Ethos CSI, developed by Gregory Talik (Ethos Pool Services, 2026), applies the USGS PHREEQC ion-association model with Plummer and Busenberg (1982) calcite constants and Truesdell-Jones activity coefficients to pool water, with ionic strength from conductivity, cyanurate and borate alkalinity removed, and a working range centered on calculated calcite equilibrium (0.00). The paper compares the Ethos CSI with PHREEQC (phreeqc.dat and pitzer.dat), the PoolMath (Falk) CSI and Falk’s full speciation spreadsheet, the Wojtowicz revised equation, and the Orenda app. It covers validation on 76 test waters, an empirical emulation of the Orenda app on 35 readings from 50 to 104 F, a check of the PoolMath app on five test waters, a crosswalk converting Ethos CSI values to the PoolMath and Orenda scales by temperature and salt, the pH ceiling and its temperature dependence, a measurement error budget, and published target ranges for ongoing service and plaster startups. On the same water, PoolMath reads 0.04 to 0.16 below the Ethos CSI, with the gap shrinking as water warms, and the Orenda app reads 0.14 to 0.18 below. No controlled study validating specific saturation index targets against plaster or equipment outcomes was found; the ranges discussed are working values for field evaluation. Reproduction scripts and app logs are available from the author on request.
Author: Talik, Gregory
Institution: Ethos (United Kingdom)
Language: English
Subfield: Health, Toxicology and Mutagenesis
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236306910
