Work

Structural and Conceptual Constraints Limiting Biological Invasion Management to Incremental Wins

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The management of biological invasions is increasingly characterised by a sequence of incremental wins and recurring management losses, whereas invasion pressure, ecological impacts, and socio-economic costs continue to rise globally. Here, we propose that this pattern reflects systemic constraints in post-introduction management, rather than a lack of effort, knowledge, or intent. We conceptualise invasion outcomes as the joint product of non-native species' impacts and spread and propose that these dimensions are intertwined and context-dependent, ultimately showing that this view can help explain why many management actions tend to fail at larger spatial scales. To do so, we highlight three cross-cutting constraints on management efficacy: (i) ethical and social constraints that shape what is politically permissible rather than ecologically optimal, (ii) structural barriers that keep management successes incremental, including context-specificity of invasion processes, weak counterfactual evaluation, and misaligned management incentives, and (iii) governance tools that are rarely assessed for net outcomes relative to no-action baselines. We suggest that invasion science could benefit from moving beyond activity-based metrics towards more explicit objectives, standardised reporting, and transparent evaluation of management effectiveness. Treating management as an optimisation problem rather than a catalogue of isolated interventions would enable more precise assessment of trade-offs, foster genuine innovation, and clarify when incremental wins are the best achievable outcome rather than a symptom of systemic failure.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,690
OpenAlex ID: W7236312281
FWCI:
Cites: 113
Cited by:
Related to: 10