Work

Simulated Likeness Substituted for Personal Endorsement: When a Likeness Speaks in Someone's Name

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This conceptual paper introduces Simulated Likeness Substituted for Personal Endorsement, a structural constraint on what a recognizable voice, appearance, or manner can establish about a person’s assent. It distinguishes three questions. Who gave permission to create or use the likeness? What evidence shows that the person endorsed the particular words or action, or authorized that commitment in advance? What grounds support a judgment about what the person would have said or done? In 1997, a Dirt Devil commercial used footage of Fred Astaire dancing with a hat rack and replaced the rack with a vacuum cleaner. Astaire had performed the dance. The advertisement gave it a new purpose. His widow, Robyn Astaire, authorized the use and cited his earlier routines with household props as grounds for believing he would have approved. His daughter, Ava Astaire McKenzie, objected that the advertisement betrayed his values. The accounts document that disagreement and leave Astaire’s own endorsement of the commercial unestablished. In 2019, NHK presented a digital likeness of Hibari Misora performing “Arekara,” a new song with lyrics by Yasushi Akimoto. Misora’s son agreed to the project and supplied recordings. Yamaha synthesized the singing voice from recordings of Misora, while others chose what the likeness would sing and say. Published accounts describe admiration for the voice and objections to putting new words in her mouth. Whether viewers understood those words as Misora’s own position remains open. Part of the Presence Through Technology series within On Human Modeling, the paper draws on Erving Goffman’s distinction among the animator who delivers an utterance, the author who chooses its words, and the principal whose position it expresses. A potential application in human–AI interaction is a museum audio guide that uses an artist’s synthesized voice to deliver a curator’s interpretation. The artist’s letters might support the interpretation’s fidelity to their views. Crediting that particular judgment to the artist would require evidence of what the artist approved.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236339890
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10