Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Afforestation and reforestation (A/R) are widely promoted as carbon dioxide removal (CDR) strategies, yet their climate change mitigation potential depends not only on forest establishment but on whether carbon removals remain additional, durable and verifiable over time. Here we conceptualize A/R as a ‘process chain’ of coupled decisions, from site selection and establishment pathway, through stewardship, carbon storage, as well as monitoring, reporting, and verification, in which choices made at one stage constrain or shape carbon outcomes at subsequent stages. Our synthesis shows that the climate effectiveness and credibility of A/R-as-CDR are highly contingent on context: carbon sequestration rates vary across climates, soils, species and management regimes, while the durability of stored carbon can be threatened by wildfire, drought, pests, and land-use change, with the latter often driven by shifting governance conditions. Even when tree cover increases, claimed carbon removals can also be undermined by failures in governance and social legitimacy, biophysical and operational readiness, as well as accounting and verification. We therefore argue that A/R should be evaluated not by hectares planted, but by whether it delivers additional, measurable, verifiable, and durable net carbon removals from the atmosphere under conditions of social legitimacy and accountable governance. This framework reveals how risks interact across stages, how failures propagate through the system, and where interventions can improve the durability and credibility of net removals. A/R can therefore contribute meaningfully to climate mitigation, but should complement, rather than substitute for, rapid and sustained emissions reductions.
Authors: Amali Amali(Conceptualization, Methodology, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing), Steffen Swoboda(Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Writing – review & editing), Wenkai Bao(Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing), Mirco Wölfelschneider(Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing), Wolfgang Obermeier(Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing), Felix Havermann(Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing), Karen Holl(Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing), Julia Pongratz(Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Methodology, Resources, Supervision, Writing – review & editing)
Language: English
Topic: Forest Management and Policy
Subfield: Forestry
Domain: Life Sciences
SDGs: Climate action, Life on land
Open Access status: green
Awards: Carbon Removal Atlas - Entwicklung einer Informationsplattform zur interaktiven Darstellung relevanter Information zu Carbon Dioxide Removal Maßnahmen, Verbundprojekt CDR: Überprüfung der Machbarkeit von terrestrischen CDR-Potenzialen unter sozio-ökologischen Randbedingungen (STEPSEC) - Teilprojekt 1: Szenarienentwicklung, nationale und internationale Modellierung von CDR-Potenzialen, REGULUS-Verbundvorhaben: LabForest - Reallabor Universitätsforst für nachhaltiges Verjüngungsmanagement im Klimawandel, Teilprojekt 1, Verbundprojekt CDR: CDR Synthese- und Transferprojekt (CDRSynTra) - Teilprojekt 1: Erdsystemmodellierung, Synthese, Koordination und Transfer
OpenAlex ID: W7236352562
