Work

Two Halves, One Index: Testing Whether a Growth/Value Split of the S&P 500 Escapes the Index's Concentration

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The S&P 500 is sold as diversification, yet in November 2026 its ten largest companies made up 37 percent of the index, and its 503 companies carried the concentration of 48 securities held in equal weights. This bulletin tests whether an investor can keep nearly the same universe while shedding part of that concentration, by holding the index's growth and value halves in a fixed, value-leaning proportion. Two ETF pairs are compared: iShares IVW/IVE (S&P 500 Growth/Value) and Vanguard VUG/VTV (CRSP US Large Cap Growth/Value). S&P's rule splits about a third of the index between both halves, making Apple the largest holding of the S&P 500 Value index; CRSP's rule places every mega-cap in the growth half. Fixed blends rebalanced annually from 2004 to 2026 kept SPY's volatility, and a 40 percent VUG blend held 78 effective securities against the index's 48 while finishing slightly ahead of SPY. The blends' active returns are not explained by the Fama–French factors alone: the SPY-minus-RSP return spread, a proxy for concentration leadership, adds significant explanatory power and survives a large-company value factor, momentum and five-factor controls, a technology-sector control and a within-technology version. For the 40 percent VUG blend, a Shapley decomposition attributes 55 percent of model-explained active variance (29 percent of the total) to the spread and 33 percent to value; for the S&P blend, the proportions roughly reverse. The protection is against concentration unwinding, not market crashes. The neutral split gauges tilt depth but shows no forecasting power.
Language: English
Subfield: Finance
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236355619
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10