Displacement or complementarity? Social media, television and cross-platform verification in Pakistan
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Is social media replacing television in Pakistan, or are audiences using the two together? This study tests competing expectations from media displacement theory and media complementarity theory using survey data from 2,000 adults in Lahore, Karachi, Peshawar and Quetta. Respondents rated statements capturing perceived displacement (declining credibility and viewership of electronic media; rising significance of social media), complementary practices (moving from social media stories to mainstream media; counter-checking social media information on electronic media; treating social media as an initial rather than a credible source; social media's reach into social issues) and functional differentiation (using social media more for entertainment than for news). All seven statements drew more agreement than disagreement (exact sign tests, Holm-adjusted p < .001). However, complementarity statements were endorsed far more strongly (mean agreement 59.4%) than displacement statements (48.1%). Counter-checking social media information on electronic media (63.4% agree vs. 22.0% disagree; Cohen's h = 0.51) and social media's penetration into social issues (64.9% vs. 20.0%; h = 0.56) produced the largest effects, while perceived decline of electronic media produced the smallest (h = 0.11). Within-person comparisons confirmed that counter-checking was endorsed more strongly than decline (conservative paired t(1999) ≥ 7.84, p < .001). The findings indicate that Pakistani audiences experience the rise of social media not as a simple replacement of television but as a reorganisation of roles in a hybrid media system: social media serve as the first alert and the arena for social issues, while electronic media serve as the place to confirm. Implications for broadcasters, verification practices and theory are discussed.
Source: Perspectives in Social Sciences
DOI: 10.63468/pss.201
Institution: Islamia University of Bahawalpur
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236357600
