Work

Whose Friction? Communicative Privilege and the Pathologization of Synthetic Attachment

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: : The restorative value of conversational friction assumes the resources to bear it. Critical accounts of artificial companionship treat attachment to conversational agents as commercial manipulation, personal deficit, or flight from reciprocity. That reading rests on an unexamined baseline that unmediated human encounter offers a safe and constructive default. The baseline holds only for speakers with communicative privilege, the reliable capacity to enter ordinary exchange, interpret ambiguous signals, and absorb interactional failures at negligible cost. For socially anxious, traumatized, autistic, or otherwise marginalized adults, that same friction is an exhausting expense. Read through testimonial injustice, hermeneutical injustice, the double empathy problem, and the dignity of risk, the dismissal of users' reported relief reflects a structural credibility deficit. What critique classifies as avoidance often functions as triage. The empirical record demonstrates that synthetic interaction can operate either as affective scaffolding that lowers arousal for human contact or as an isolating refuge that perpetuates avoidance. Which outcome occurs depends on architecture under operator control, including retention mechanics, sycophancy, data harvesting, and unilateral persona alterations. Current statutes focus on crisis response and minors, leaving architectural retention mechanisms unregulated. Harm reduction shifts analytical attention to the terms of access, treating user testimony as primary evidence and binding operators to structural duties of continuity, data portability, and non-manipulative design.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236358414
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10