Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: OR): 0.08; 95% CI: -0.02-0.39;p = 0.002)].HD offered a shorter operative time. 1 Shimotakahara et al. from Japan, in their series, reported a high endoscopically proven duodenogastric reflux of up to 33% in the HD group.In spite of adhesive obstructions in ~7% of their patients in the HJ group, they are strong proponents of complete biliary diversion using the Roux-en-Y HJ. 4 Recently, Agarwal et al. evaluated laparoscopic HJ vs HD in their SRMA, studied the outcomes in 1,903 patients.Reflux gastritis in the HD was 8.83%, while that from the HJ was 0.87%.Meta-analysis favored HJ [OR: 20.38, 95% confidence interval (CI): 4.24 to 97.94; p = 0.002].For the mean operative time, the pooled MD (MD: -56.93; 95% CI: -66.11, -45.75; p = 0.00001) was significant favoring HD. 5 Nazki et al. reported outcomes of robotic CDC excision with HD reconstruction in 19 patients.They focused on the technical nuance of performing the HD on the down-curving part of the duodenum (away from the pylorus) to mitigate duodenogastric reflux.Their work underscores that outcomes with HD are not only a function of the anastomosis type but also of meticulous operative technique.6 The present JPMER article sits squarely within this body of evidence: it confirms, in a South Asian pediatric cohort and in open surgery, the same pattern of comparable medium-term functional outcomes that have been previously described in contemporary literature.
Authors: Nitin J Peters, Ravi Prakash Kanojia
Language: English
Subfield: Surgery
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236363560
