The Lauderdale manuscript sale of 25 January 1692: what the catalogue titles are, and where some of the lots went
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The manuscripts of John Maitland, Duke of Lauderdale (1616–1682), were offered at auction by Jo. Bullord at Tom's Coffee-house, London, on 25 January 1691/2, in a four-page appendix to the catalogue Bibliotheca instructissima, headed Bibliotheca Manuscripta Lauderdaliana. The appendix lists 94 numbered lots and was reprinted in The Bannatyne Miscellany, vol. II (Edinburgh, 1836), pp. 151–58. This paper does two things. It asks what kind of text the catalogue's entries are. Bodleian MS. Savile 55 (lot 35), whose fol. 1r Peter Kidd had already described as matching the auction entry, is compared here item by item with the Digital Bodleian facsimile: the entry reproduces a sixteenth-century list of contents written in the right margin of that leaf, including its misattribution of Campanus of Novara's De quadratura circuli to Archimedes and its closing connective nec non, and it preserves words that the binder later cropped from the leaf. Two British Library manuscripts from the same sale show the same relation between an added heading and the printed entry. The catalogue's titles are therefore best read as copies of owners' labels, not as descriptions of the texts. It then sets out, with an explicit owner and confidence for each, what is known or proposed about where the lots went, giving particular attention to the manuscripts that reached Samuel Pepys. It records that the identification of lots 15 and 79 with the two Maitland manuscripts now in the Pepys Library was made in print in 1836 by the editor of the reprint; that an undated note by Francis Wormald (Magdalene College, Pepys Scholars' Library, MCPSL/4/6, item 1a) places those two volumes, a copy of Balfour's Practicks and a Regiam Majestatem in this catalogue and proposes that Pepys acquired some of his most interesting medieval books at this sale; and that lot 16, whose entry names the library of Peterhouse, Cambridge, agrees with the recorded history of Pepys Library MS 2329. Lot 74, Cabala, sive Tractatus Astrologico-magicus, remains unidentified. The paper ends with tests that could be carried out on the Pepys manuscripts themselves, and with a statement of what was and was not checked. Not peer reviewed. Prepared for the Pepys Scholars Library, Magdalene College, Cambridge. Wormald's note (MCPSL/4/6, item 1a) is summarised, not reproduced. Section 9 states which sources were checked and which were not. Files: the paper (PDF and Markdown source); savile55_lot35_wordcount.py, the word count of §3.1. Use of AI: Claude (Anthropic) assisted with catalogue searches, working notes, the word count and drafting; the author is responsible for every statement.
Author: Teker, Onur
Language: English
Subfield: History
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236370035
