Work

A Workflow-Based Hybrid Framework Linking SOC Evidence with Threats, Weaknesses and Decision Constraints for Public-Sector Cybersecurity Risk Assessment

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Title A Workflow-Based Hybrid Framework Linking SOC Evidence with Threats, Weaknesses and Decision Constraints for Public-Sector Cybersecurity Risk Assessment*, by David Gyan and Jojo Lartey (Heritage Christian University, Ghana). It is an IEEE-style manuscript of about 10 pages. ProblemPublic-sector institutions face growing cyber threats. Their decisions are slowed by governance, resource and organisational limits. Security Operations Centres (SOCs) produce event-based evidence, but that evidence is often not connected to strategic risk assessment. Proposed solutionThe paper presents the *SOC–TWDC framework*. It is a conceptual architectural framework that combines SOC evidence with Threats, Weaknesses and Decision Constraints (TWDC). Its main design choice is to keep weaknesses separate from decision constraints. A weakness is a deficiency. A constraint is a condition that limits what can be approved or implemented, such as budget, staffing, policy or authority. Artefact- Three layers: SOC Evidence, TWDC Assessment, and Workflow and Decision-Support.- Nine linked information objects, including the TWDC Assessment Matrix and the Decision-Traceability Record.- A ten-stage conditional workflow with escalation and traceability.- Ten literature-derived design requirements (DR1–DR10).- A synthetic scenario about repeated privileged-account authentication failures. Method- Design Science Research is the overall methodology.- Evaluation is formative and has two strands. - A bounded comparison with NIST CSF 2.0, ISO/IEC 27005:2022, Open FAIR, OCTAVE Allegro and event-based assessment. - A 20-item Likert questionnaire completed by six purposively sampled cybersecurity professionals from about four public institutions. It also had three open-ended questions.- Five research questions (RQ1–RQ5) guide the study. Key results- Construct means ranged from 4.03 (Usability/Practicality) to 4.53 (TWDC Modelling).- The other two constructs were SOC Integration (4.40) and Workflow Operationalisation (4.50).- Exploratory Cronbach's alpha ranged from 0.747 to 0.912.- Five qualitative themes emerged: skills and capacity, governance and regulation, flexible implementation, technology and infrastructure, and roles and coordination. Conclusions and limitsThe framework appears conceptually plausible and potentially useful for clarity, accountability and traceability. It may complement established standards rather than replace them. The paper does not claim effectiveness or generalisability. The reasons are the small sample, the lack of operational testing and the lack of formal content validation. Future work includes experimental simulation, a controlled pilot, a software prototype and mapping to ISO/IEC 27005 and NIST CSF 2.0. StructureThe sections are I Introduction, II Related Work, III Method, IV The Artefact, V Results, VI Discussion, VII Limitations and VIII Conclusion. They are followed by 31 references. The paper includes 7 tables and 4 figures.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236373189
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10