Work

Handoff zones as the unit of analysis for AI accountability

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Gap-based frameworks for AI accountability locate failure in static gaps: the responsibility gap, the liability gap, the accountability gap, the problem of many hands, the moral crumple zone, and Santoni de Sio and Mecacci’s four-part elaboration of the responsibility gap. Lifecycle approaches now emerging in policy literature extend accountability across a system’s evolution and value chain, including through monitoring, re-evaluation, and information sharing among actors. This paper asks a narrower question: whether, for the class of failures it takes as its object, the temporally extended relationship between actors should itself be treated as the primary unit of analysis. This paper develops the handoff zone as the appropriate primary unit of analysis for AI accountability failures characterized by temporal accumulation, asynchronous assumptions among actors, and recursive interdependence across a deployment chain. A handoff zone is the temporally extended envelope across which one actor transfers a system, a responsibility, or a set of expectations to another actor operating on asymmetric and evolving assumptions about the first. The framework draws on aviation human factors and patient safety literatures, where temporally extended handoff failures have been studied empirically for decades. Using Mobley v. Workday as its central case, supplemented by a hypothetical upstream provider transfer, the paper examines handoff relationships across the deployment chain and the downstream point at which their consequences reach applicants. Frameworks currently in use (risk-based classification, model documentation, audit, and lifecycle approaches) each do substantive analytical work; handoff-zone analysis makes the temporal envelope across which actors’ assumptions are renegotiated its primary object of analysis.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,520
OpenAlex ID: W7236374950
FWCI:
Cites: 28
Cited by:
Related to: 10