Work

The Goal-Process Semantic Nullification Theory (GPSNT): A General Theory of Goal-Constitutive Process Contradiction and Systemic Consequences

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper develops the Goal-Process Semantic Nullification Theory (GPSNT), a proposed general theoretical framework for examining whether a system, or an agent operating within it, pursues a defined objective through a process whose structure directly conflicts with the objective's specified meaning, rationale, constitutive conditions, normative basis, or functional purpose. The central research question asks whether such a conflict can arise consciously, unconsciously, indirectly, or automatically, and under what conditions it undermines, nullifies, or turns the process against the objective, or manifests as contradiction, paradox, divergence, or dilemma.The theory distinguishes goal-constitutive process contradiction (GPCC) from the stronger condition of goal-process semantic nullification (GPSN). It also separates intention from process correctness, legal or normative compliance from outcome effectiveness, the existence of a contradiction from its causal consequences, and a single event from a persistent system-level pattern. The primary illustrative case is the Law-Enforcer's Prohibited-Means Inversion Case (LEPMIC), in which an officer seeks to control prohibited weapon conduct while engaging in the same type of conduct under the stipulated conditions of the case.The proposed architecture contains eighteen layers, a cross-domain research programme, a formal variable system, a classification of outcomes, testable hypotheses, operationalization rules, counterexamples, and a staged research protocol. Connections to organizational theory, deontic logic, systems theory, cybernetics, causal inference, public administration, and policing research are specified without treating those fields as interchangeable.The paper is a theoretical proposal, not a report of completed empirical experiments. The originality, generality, measurement reliability, and empirical validity of the proposed framework remain open to comparative literature review and independent testing.Keywords: goal-process contradiction; semantic nullification; systemic self-defeat; institutional processes; goal displacement; deontic logic; systems theory; cybernetics; causal inference; procedural legitimacy
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236401561
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10