The Floor Price: Minimum Unit Pricing After the Uprating and the Distribution of a Price Floor in Scotland's Alcohol Market
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: On 30 September 2024 Scotland raised its minimum unit price for alcohol from 50 to 65 pence, six years after the floor first took effect and after a parliamentary vote that kept a policy otherwise due to lapse under its own sunset clause. Wales followed on 1 October 2026. The uprating is usually discussed as a public health decision, and the evidence for the original floor is usually summarised in a single figure: an estimated 13.4 per cent reduction in deaths wholly attributable to alcohol over its first 32 months. This paper reads the uprating instead as a market intervention, and asks four questions of it that the public health framing tends to set aside. Who pays the higher floor and who gains from it; how much demand leaves the regulated Scottish market for cross-border, online or illicit supply; whether a floor is an adequate substitute for restrictions on marketing; and where the revenue a floor creates actually goes. The analysis draws on the Public Health Scotland evaluation, the Scottish Government's business and regulatory impact assessment for the uprating, as corrected in December 2025, a 2026 model-based appraisal, and mortality and sales series published up to October 2026. It finds that the 65 pence floor is a materially larger intervention than the 50 pence floor was on introduction, binding on an estimated 64 per cent of off-trade alcohol by volume in 2022 against 45 per cent below 50 pence in the year before launch; that the transfer it creates accrues to retailers, chiefly in the off-trade, while modelled alcohol tax receipts fall; that the evidence on cross-border and illicit substitution remains thin rather than reassuring; and that the appraisal on which Parliament voted contained a modelling error that reduced the first-year estimate of deaths averted from 60 to 38 once corrected. None of this makes the case against a floor. It does make the case for indexation in statute, for recovering the retail transfer, and for a higher standard of published correction in the modelling on which price policy now depends.
Author: Jenkins, Alan
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236408073
