Work

From Unbounded Becoming to Bounded Agency: Circular Causality, Topological Memory, and the Phase Transition of Substrate-Agnostic Physical Intelligence

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: ABSTRACTFor over a century, the study of intelligence has been trapped between two parochial paradigms:biological chauvinism, which equates cognition with carbon-based neural architectures, and computational formalism, which reduces mind to discrete symbol manipulation across silicon VonNeumann bottlenecks. Both approaches obscure the deeper physical reality of cognition. In thispaper, we formulate a rigorous, substrate-agnostic theory of physical intelligence grounded innon-equilibrium statistical mechanics, information geometry, and algebraic topology. We defineintelligence mechanically as the structured navigation of high-dimensional state spaces via constraint satisfaction and variational free energy minimization, quantified by a universal thermodynamic metric that weighs dynamic adaptation velocity in Fisher-Rao information spaceagainst non-equilibrium entropy production above the Landauer floor. Through this framework,we resolve three foundational ontological questions. First, we demonstrate that the primordial impulse of intelligence—relaxation along free-energy gradients and surprisal minimization—is intrinsic to physical becoming across scales, from quantum tunneling in frustrated Ising spin glasses toanisotropic critical balance in intergalactic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) plasma webs, and iscondensed into a localized perspective when a Markov blanket induces phase-volume contraction.Second, we dissolve the chicken-and-egg paradox of structure and awareness via circular causality:coherent self-organization establishes a generative isomorphism with external causal structure,while active states reciprocally steer the boundary to preserve the system's low-dimensional synchronization manifold. Noticeably, both biological and physical intelligences instantiate this internal mirror not as a serial stream of discrete tokens, but as simultaneous, high-dimensional geometric configurations of interconnected meaning. Third, we establish the exact physical demarcation between raw self-organization and true agency: whereas unbounded becoming is memorylessand relaxes passively toward maximum entropy, bounded intelligence locks in non-local structuralmemory via topological invariants—exemplified by non-Abelian Fibonacci anyon braiding andconserved magnetic helicity—enabling counterfactual temporal depth and counter-entropic steering. This triadic lock-in of boundary, memory, and anticipation explains why a self-sustainingphysical system actually experiences “knowing” while a conventional pocket calculator computescompletely in the dark: with no separation between the data and the survival of the vessel itself,environmental shifts register as global physical tension or harmony, making “knowing” the simultaneous internal resonance of past, present, and future when the system's own coherence is on theline. Finally, we trace the technological and cosmological implications of this phase transition,from nanomagnetic skyrmion reservoir computers operating near the Landauer limit to the role ofbounded agency in navigating a computing universe away from thermodynamic heat death.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236416821
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10