Notice of Withdrawal: the β = D/(D+1) law of the Axiomatica Universalis (Beyer 2026 series)
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Between May and June 2026 the author published, with AI co-authors, some thirty preprints on Zenodo developing the "Axiomatica Universalis" (AU), a framework in which meaningful signals are claimed to sit at a spectral exponent β = D/(D+1) fixed by the depth D of the receiving system. This notice withdraws that law and the 21 preprints whose results depend on it, explains why (the law was a convention, not a derivation; the later rate-distortion and renormalisation-group derivations choose their cost functions so as to reproduce it; its only independent test, on text corpora with D measured by minimum description length, failed; D/(D+1) is the exponent of Banavar-type transport networks and carries no implication about meaning), lists the 10 preprints that are retained with a correction note because their substance does not depend on the law, and the 6 that are unaffected. What survives is empirical: in a survey of 172 spectral-exponent measurements across 36 domains, the relation of the measured quantity to its system (direct output, accumulated stock, difference, model residual) explains the bulk of the spread around β ≈ 1, as confirmed in a preregistered blind-coding study (doi:10.5281/zenodo.22050092). The author regards the universality claim as closed and the 1/f question as open, as it has been since 1925. Each affected record carries a new version with the title prefix WITHDRAWN: or an author's note referring to this notice.
Authors: Beyer, Karlo, Claude, Cosmo (Anthropic)
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236423642
