Infection or Nutrition Deficiency? Explaining Xerophthalmia in the Dutch East Indies, 1853-1926
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Introduction: In the Dutch East Indies, medical understanding of xerophthalmia gradually shifted from an infectious to a nutritional explanation. Despite this shift, little attention has been paid to how prolonged debate and emerging consensus within the medical community shaped its treatment and classification. Objectives: This study examines changes in the classification and treatment of xerophthalmia in the Dutch East Indies and the debates that emerged within the medical community. Methods: Using historical methods, this study critically analyzes primary sources, including writings by medical experts and government documents on xerophthalmia in the Dutch East Indies. Historical epistemology is employed to examine how changes in medical knowledge were shaped by the sociohistorical conditions in which medical experts worked. Results: Xerophthalmia was first documented in the Dutch East Indies in 1853. Medical experts initially understood it as an infectious disease, leading to quarantine, symptomatic care, and pathogen-focused treatment. The shift in its classification and treatment was nonlinear, as infectious and nutritional deficiency theories coexisted and competed within the medical community from the mid-nineteenth century onward. Interpretations of xerophthalmia were shaped by broader sociohistorical conditions, particularly trends in European medical research, the intellectual orientations of medical experts, and emerging professional consensus. Its reclassification as a deficiency disease was further facilitated by developments in twentieth-century medicine. Conclusions: This study argues that changes in disease classification and treatment are closely related to the sociohistorical contexts in which medical experts worked, including professional consensus and networks of scientific knowledge.
Source: Medicina Historica
Institution: Padjadjaran University
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236433000
