Performance in Scientific Discourses Hosted in Generic Studio Settings: A Comparative Analysis of Citizen’s Kenya’s Gold and Shamba Shape-Up
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study compares the production design and audience impact of two agricultural programmes broadcast on Citizen TV (Royal Media Services): Kenya's Gold and Shamba Shape-Up. Despite sharing an agricultural focus and an entertainment-education purpose, the two programmes report markedly different audience outcomes. The study draws on Entertainment-Education theory, Social Learning Theory and Performance Theory, and uses a qualitative comparative case study design. It combines close textual analysis of ten purposively sampled episodes per programme (January 2025 to May 2026) with thematic analysis of twelve sampled YouTube comments for Kenya's Gold and secondary analysis of the Shamba Shape-Up Series 15 impact report (N=600 smallholder farmers). Findings point to two divergent paradigms. Kenya's Gold follows a studio-based, journalist-led, aesthetic-driven model in which artificial sets, costumes, and scripted presentation create what this study terms a "performative deficit": a theory-practice disconnect that shifts attention to the presenters. Shamba Shape-Up follows a field-based, actor-facilitated, problem-solving model shot on working farms, where concepts are demonstrated in context and support observational learning. The study concludes that scientific content about objective reality is better represented in context-specific settings. It recommends that producers of such programmes use appropriate contexts, strengthen audience feedback mechanisms, and conduct regular audience impact assessments.
DOI: 10.51317/jvs80938
Author: Okutu Dennis Lijondo
Institution: Kabarak University
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236442400
