Three Unities of an Unread Script: Dating, Defining and Delimiting Rongorongo
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: In 2024 a radiocarbon date of about 1500 for one inscribed board from Rapa Nui (Easter Island) was offered as evidence that rongorongo, the island's undeciphered script, may be one of the few independent inventions of writing. Critics replied that the date belongs to a tree, not to an inscription, and that nothing shows the signs record speech until someone reads them. This article, a case study in Xenosophy, the inquiry into contact between sides whose nature and boundary are not given in advance, argues that the quarrel is staged, like a neoclassical tragedy, under unities of its own: one event to be dated, an invention; one criterion, decipherment, for deciding whether signs record language; and one object, a single script. Not every party needs all three. The dating study, it shows, dates a board's outer edge under an assumed rate of growth, misdescribes its own modelled dates, and sets aside the oldest date before naming a phase after the script. It separates recognising that signs record speech from translating them, and describes tests that bear on the first without the second, each calibrated first on known cases. It asks whether the surviving objects hold several traditions under one name, testing groups of tablets fixed in advance by wood, hand and lineage. Hypotheses about the tablets' purpose are developed and some discarded. It does not speak for the Rapanui, absent from the debate. Many of its hypotheses were first formulated in work with AI systems; none is claimed as new.
Author: Sokoloff, Valery
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236445748
