Computation is Neither Cognition nor Intelligence: Toward a Sociotechnical Re-Conception of Artificial Intelligence
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become one of the most influential technologies shaping contemporary society. Despite rapid advances in machine learning, foundation models, and generative AI, persistent ambiguity remains concerning the relationship among computation, cognition, and intelligence. While computational systems demonstrate increasingly sophisticated capabilities, whether such capabilities constitute cognition or intelligence remains theoretically contested. Existing scholarship has extensively examined AI technologies, applications, ethics, and governance, yet comparatively less attention has been devoted to explaining how computational systems become associated with intelligence and acquire legitimacy, authority, and societal significance.This study investigates AI conception as a distinct object of interdisciplinary inquiry. Using a conceptual, abductive, and theory-building approach, it synthesizes insights from philosophy of mind, cognitive science, Science and Technology Studies, sociotechnical systems theory, communication studies, institutional theory, and governance scholarship. The analysis develops the AI Re-Conception Framework, comprising five interconnected dimensions: Terminological Reconstruction, Discursive Reconstruction, Epistemological Reconstruction, Sociotechnical Reconstruction, and Human-Centered Governance Integration.The framework explains how computational systems acquire intelligence-related attribution, meaning, legitimacy, and governance relevance through processes of categorization, interpretation, attribution, relational embedding, and conceptual governance. It argues that intelligence attribution emerges through human interpretation and justification rather than computational capability itself. Consequently, computation should not be conflated with cognition or intelligence.The study advances a sociotechnical re-conception of AI, establishes AI conception as a distinct object of inquiry, and introduces Conceptual Governance as a framework for examining and governing the assumptions and legitimacy claims through which AI acquires societal influence.
Source: Figshare
Author: Prashant Mahajan
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236501528
