More Than Just Paper: Archives as Cultural Property and Their Implications for Past, Present, and Future in Armed Conflict
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Often considered an afterthought by military planners and states alike, both public archives and privately owned documents have been subject to targeting, seizure, and loss throughout centuries of warfare. While the current cultural property regime in international law theoretically protects most archives, recent Russian military actions in the wake of the Ukraine War militate in favor of a re-examination of archives’ status in armed conflict. A thorough re-examination is particularly timely, as extant literature has paid scant attention to the multigenerational effects of the destruction, seizure, or loss of archival documents. This Article aims to add to the existing discourse about international law and cultural property by proposing that archives—specifically, a subset deemed for the sake of analysis to be “truth files” (a term adapted from data science’s concept of “ground truth data”)—hold particular value for individuals, communities (especially displaced communities), and states (particularly those trying to preserve national narratives). Using human-oriented stories, this Article will demonstrate the value of archival truth files. The primary case studies include the experience of descendants of Poles attempting to exercise citizenship rights based on destroyed archival documents; the experience of the Iraqi Jewish diaspora in relation to its unlawfully seized cultural property; and the current experience of Ukraine, whose archives Russia has seized or destroyed in what this Article argues is an effort to suppress unfavorable historical narratives. Ultimately, because of the unique nature of truth files, states should focus on this subset of cultural property and subject it to more proactive marking efforts. Archival documents are not simply pieces of paper to be destroyed or seized based on military expediency or ulterior motives, but rather vehicles carrying profound meanings for individuals, communities, and states.
Institution: Georgetown University
Language: English
Subfield: Conservation
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236536633
