Work

Cognitive Structure of Text Comprehension: A Psychometric Study of PIRLS-Format Items Among Primary School Students in Uzbekistan

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Background. The cognitive-process model used in the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS) has rarely been tested in multilingual, non-Anglophone education systems. This study examined how the four PIRLS reading processes relate to one another among fourth-grade students in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, whether students perform differently across these processes, and whether these differences vary by language of instruction. Methods. In a cross-sectional design, students completed two literary texts on a digital assessment platform; after exclusion of incomplete protocols, 1,835 entered the analysis of the first text and 2,231 the second. Each text carried 14 dichotomously and polytomously scored PIRLS-format items covering retrieval, straightforward inference, interpretation and evaluation. Analyses comprised descriptive and reliability statistics, exploratory factor analysis, repeated measures analysis of variance on a common proportion-of-maximum metric, and comparisons between Uzbek-medium and Russian-medium students. Results. Internal consistency was acceptable for the full 14-item scale of each text (α = .733 and .740) but low for the four process subscales (α = .298–.597), so process-level findings are provisional. Three factors emerged in each text, with a basic component combining retrieval and inference items, but the remaining factors differed between texts. Cognitive process exerted a large within-subject effect (η² p = .678 and .758): performance fell significantly at every step from retrieval to evaluation in the first text, whereas in the second retrieval and inference did not differ and evaluation exceeded interpretation (d z = 0.937), so the hierarchy is not monotone with cognitive demand. Russian-medium students outperformed Uzbek-medium students on every measure, most markedly for interpretation in the first text (d = 1.144); a significant Language × Process interaction (η² p = .129 and .078) showed the gap to be smallest for basic processes and largest for higher-order ones. Conclusions. The findings suggest a broad distinction between basic and higher-order comprehension rather than a consistent four-step hierarchy. The variation in process structure across texts and the larger language-group differences for higher-order processes highlight the importance of examining cognitive-process measures within specific linguistic contexts. Because process-level reliability was limited and language-group comparisons were based on observed scores without measurement-invariance testing, the findings should be interpreted as evidence of differences in assessment performance rather than established differences in underlying reading ability.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236562639
Cites: 34
Cited by:
Related to: 10