Constrained Choice Developing Into Preference Under an Identical Record: Why a Habit Begun Without Options Can Become a Real Preference
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This conceptual paper introduces Constrained Choice Developing Into Preference Under an Identical Record. A person can begin an activity because someone else requires it and later choose it because it has come to matter to them. A record of the activity can look the same across both periods. To interpret it, the paper asks what else the person could realistically have chosen, what they did when the alternatives changed, and how they describe what they now value. The Czech pianist Tomáš Kačo recalls practicing as a child to please his father and finding his own interest in music at about fifteen. When the Ostrava conservatory turned him down, he enrolled at an agricultural school. On Fridays he took the bus to study with a conservatory professor and prepare for a second audition, at which he was admitted. A practice log could show him at the piano in both periods. The Friday journeys tell us something the hours at the keyboard alone could not: once another course was open, Kačo made his own arrangements to keep studying music. Li Na recalls that a coach steered her from badminton into tennis as a child. In 2002 she left China’s national tennis program and took university classes in journalism. She returned to competition in early 2004 and later described the decision as her own. The policy that allowed her to hire her own coach and set her schedule came in 2008, four years after her return. Her time away, the alternative she pursued, and her account of coming to enjoy tennis give meaning to a competitive record that could otherwise show simply that she played. Part of Formation and Enactment in the On Human Modeling series, the paper places this distinction alongside Jon Elster’s account of adaptive preferences. One application concerns how AI recommender systems infer what a person wants from repeated selections. A booking service might record the same early train each week. It matters whether that train was once the only affordable departure, whether later trains have since become affordable, and whether the traveler has come to value arriving early.
Author: Cary, Alexandra
Language: English
Subfield: General Decision Sciences
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236567258
