Field Science in Competitive Sports: Testing Field-Based Reasoning Against Conventional Sports Models
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Competitive sports require decisions whose justification depends on changing objectives, interdependent outcomes, sporting rules, and uncertain future events. Although existing analytics, optimization, and decision-support methods already address these challenges, a recommendation's stability does not necessarily establish that its evidentiary justification remains valid. This conceptual paper investigates whether mission-conditioned Field representations can provide incremental methodological value beyond fully integrated conventional approaches. Ten constructed cases spanning football, basketball, volleyball, tennis, Formula 1, cycling, and swimming examine three overlapping evidentiary regimes: exact competitive feasibility, probabilistic decision support, and counterfactual strategic reasoning. These cases distinguish what is mathematically possible, what is estimated to be likely, and what can legitimately be inferred about unobserved alternatives. A decision-claim comparison record links each proposition to its competitive objective, relevant constraints, supporting information, temporal scope, and potential revision triggers. It separates the evidentiary status of a proposition—supported, rejected, or undetermined—from the procedural disposition to retain, reassess, suspend, or replace it following material change. An adversarial comparison protocol evaluates a Field arm against information- and resource-matched conventional systems equipped to trace dependencies, preserve provenance, and revise recommendations. Constructed controls include shifts in goals, evidentiary updates, unsupported strengthening of claims, stable decisions with altered justifications, conventional sufficiency, and observationally non-identifiable alternatives. Proposed evaluation dimensions encompass claim qualification, detection of necessary revisions, reconstruction fidelity, unwarranted certainty, and total methodological cost. The contribution is a bounded, falsifiable cross-sport research methodology, not a new prediction algorithm, causal-identification result, or established Field ontology. No original empirical comparison or Field-specific advantage is reported. Future evaluations may support bounded benefit, equivalence, negative net value, or inconclusive evidence.
Author: Figurelli, Rogério
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236567859
