The Effectiveness of Speculative Theories: From the Isomorphism of the Universe to Total Knowledge
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The article is devoted to the cognitive status of speculative theories in natural science ‒ theories arranged as formal models without direct reliance on empirical data. It is shown that Yu. Wigner's question of an “incompre-hensible effectiveness of mathematics” requires a clarification: this is not about mathematics in general but speculative theories that have received formalistic embodiment. The difference between mathematical and physical speculative theories is specific: both are built within the framework of the logic of the universe, the core of which is isomorphism. Conceptual and historical analyses, example studies like Phlogiston theory and Max-well’s equations are used. The novelty is a reformulation of the issue of the effectiveness of mathematics as a problem of a cognitive status of speculative theories and the proposal of a mechanism that does not resort to the assumption of pre-established harmony. Since isomorphism is an empirical fact, the number of patterns is finite, which makes their translation between regions possible and efficient. The phlogistic theory demonstrates that a violation of the pattern serves as a criterion for rejection rather than the falsity of the ontology. Maxwell's equations point at the fact that reducing the patterns to a syntactic shell deprives the theory of openness for the further expansion. The role of speculative theories in total cognition as elements of a multiconnected system of knowledge with combinatorial validation is substantiated.
Author: Andrey A. Gribkov
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236569914
