Work

Navigating Identity Discordance Through Values-Based MentorSHIP: An Educational Workshop Anchored in a Tool From Clinical Psychology

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Introduction: Since medical trainees and physicians identifying as female or as underrepresented in medicine often struggle to find identity-concordant mentors, structured training to support identity-discordant mentorship pairs is important for fostering diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) in medicine. This workshop for mentors and mentees aims to teach participants about identity concordance/discordance in mentorship and provide strategies for developing mentorship relationships through intentional discussion of values and self-reflection. Methods: We developed an interactive, 75-minute workshop for medical students, residents, fellows, faculty, and graduate medical education staff consisting of didactic content; small-group exercises, including a values card sort activity; and large-group reflections. We used a postworkshop survey to evaluate participants' satisfaction with and main takeaways from the workshop. We analyzed Likert-scale questions with descriptive statistics and open-ended questions with content analysis. Results: We presented the workshop at 3 local conferences in varying formats (in-person, hybrid in-person/virtual, and virtual). Fifty-four of 65 total participants completed the postworkshop survey (83% response rate). Most participants reported the workshop met its learning objectives (50/52, 96%) and they will apply the information they learned through participation in the workshop (49/52, 94%). Participants reported intended future behavior changes of value reflection and self-reflection, openness to identity-discordant mentorship pairs, thoughtfulness of mentorship type and navigation of unsuccessful mentorship relationships. Discussion: This well-received workshop promoted participant reflection surrounding concordant and discordant mentorship matches, how mentorship pairings can promote DEI in medicine, and how to discuss values with mentors/mentees to promote self-reflection and self-improvement in mentorship.
Source: MedEdPORTAL
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236573713
FWCI:
Cites: 26
Cited by:
Related to: 10