Work

From Comparison to Calculus: The Emergence of Velocity, Acceleration and Calculus in RECT

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Mainstream physics takes space, time and calculus as given: Newton describes motion with fluxions inside absolute time and space, Leibniz's differentials serve as a universal tool, u = s/t is called a definition, and acceleration is called the time derivative of velocity. The Reference Object Entropy Cycle Theory (RECT) reverses this order. The universe is the totality of reference structures and their relations, U = (S, R), with N ≥ 1 (never zero; at N = 1 relational quantities are undefined, not zero) and R(N) = N(N − 1)/2 binary relations. Structures measure one another, each simultaneously taking itself as baseline; there is no external metric. The metric arises within the relations, and the values of relations are settled by it. On this basis we derive velocity, acceleration and calculus from comparison. (i) Length, area and volume arise from mutual measurement; by the official RECT rule, volume is fundamental, and length, area and even points are different manifestations of volume, read out simultaneously. (ii) Time and distance become distinguishable only through comparison; comparing s with t, an invariant ratio yields u = s/t. (iii) Comparing u with t, an invariant Δu/Δt yields a = Δu/Δt. (iv) Shrinking the comparison scale, comparing ever smaller differences until their ratio stabilises, yields the derivatives u = ds/dt and a = d²s/dt²; the reverse comparison, accumulation, yields the integral s = ∫ u dt, and volume can be seen as an accumulated readout. Calculus is thus not a pre-existing tool but the structure that naturally forms when physical quantities are compared again and again at ever finer scales: the structure we call mathematical. The paper concerns the ontological origin of calculus; it does not re-prove theorems of analysis, and rigorous limits and real completeness are used as in existing mathematics. Logic itself also arises in the comparison of different physical quantities. Continued comparison yields further quantities (acceleration with mass gives force; force with distance gives work), illustrating RECT's strongest prediction: comparing physical quantities with one another necessarily yields new, as-yet-unknown physical relations and quantities. Comparison extends to geometry itself: curvature, too, is obtained from comparison, and all mathematics rests on comparison. Comparing a triangle's angle sum with π, a circumference with 2πr, or a volume with its flat counterpart reads out curvature; Gauss's Theorema Egregium shows that internal comparison alone suffices, matching the absence of any external metric; on relation networks, deficit angles, Ollivier–Ricci curvature and the flatness test of the distance matrix apply directly. Comparing a vector with itself after parallel transport around a small loop gives the Riemann tensor, whose averages are the Ricci and scalar curvatures on the left side of the Einstein equation; comparing the accelerations of neighbouring structures (tides) recovers ∇²Φ = 4πGρ in the Newtonian limit (Section 10). Since logic, calculus and curvature all come from comparison, coordinate systems do too: double-centring and eigen-decomposing the distance matrix yields coordinates, with the centroid of all structures as origin, the eigen-directions of B as axes and the rank as the number of axes; rotations, reflections and translations leave every relational reading unchanged. Coordinates are a way of reading; relations are the content. Signs also come from comparison: "more than" and "less than" give plus and minus, determinant signs give orientation, Sylvester's law of inertia keeps the numbers of positive and negative eigenvalues of B invariant, and comparing spacetime intervals reads out the signature (−, +, +, +) (Section 11). The world is volumetric from the start, so it is a³: the ladder from points to lines to areas is logically untenable, and lower exponents are readings compared out of volume (a³/a = a², a³/a² = a, a³/a³ = 1), with exponent 3 corresponding to a spatial readout of rank 3. The inverse-square law follows: a conserved number of relations spread evenly over the shell dV/dr = 4πr² gives an action falling as 1/(4πr²), the exponent being 2 = 3 − 1 (Section 12).
Author: Fang, Daniel
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236574157
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10