Beyond Fact ,beyond Faith:towards an Epistemic Afromodality
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The opposition of scientific fact and religious faith is a familiar starting point for modern debates about knowledge, but it does not adequately describe either scientific practice or religious life. Science depends on observation, measurement, modelling and critical testing, yet its claims are also theory-laden, probabilistic and reversible. Religious traditions make claims through revelation, trust, interpretation, testimony and lived transformation; these claims cannot simply be translated into laboratory hypotheses. That is to say that, human knowing is often presented through a binary epistemological model in which science is associated with fact, evidence and empirical verification, while religion is associated with faith, revelation and transcendence. Although this distinction is useful, it becomes inadequate when treated as an absolute division between what can be known and what can only be believed. Contemporary developments in science, particularly quantum physics, cosmology, artificial intelligence and the study of consciousness, increasingly reveal the significance of probability, uncertainty, theoretical possibility and interpretative structures within scientific inquiry itself. Similarly, religious faith cannot be reduced to irrational or evidentially empty belief, since it incorporates reason, experience, tradition, interpretation and existential commitment. This paper, therefore, moves beyond the conventional fact–faith dichotomy and proposes an Afromodal philosophy of knowing grounded in the recognition of multiple but interconnected modes of human knowing. Drawing from Afromodalism, the paper argues that knowledge is not exhausted by empirical fact nor confined to religious faith; rather, human knowing emerges through an interplay of evidence, reason, experience, possibility, probability, intuition and meaning. The Afromodal perspective consequently seeks neither to subordinate science to religion nor religion to science, but to situate both within a broader epistemic horizon in which different modes of knowing can encounter one another without losing their distinctive identities. The paper concludes that moving beyond fact and faith is not a movement away from truth, but an invitation to rethink the plurality, relationality and situatedness of human knowing.
Author: Onebunne, Jude I.
Institution: Nnamdi Azikiwe University
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236584014
