Beyond the Counting Game: Rethinking Simplicity in the Debate Between Classical Theism and Naturalism
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: In debates over ultimate reality, philosopher Graham Oppy argues that naturalism holds a decisive advantage in theoretical simplicity over classical theism because it requires fewer axioms, primitive terms, and entities. This article critiques Oppy’s quantitative approach to theory comparison, demonstrating how it sidesteps the core metaphysical problem of why contingent reality exists at all. By contrasting Oppy’s item-counting methodology with classical metaphysics, the essay highlights four key flaws in his framework: the confusion of qualitative unity with quantitative parsimony, the additive fallacy of treating God as an object alongside the universe, the conflation of foundational axioms with contingent historical outcomes, and the mistaking of human conceptual distinctions for ontological complexity. Ultimately, defining simplicity purely by minimizing unshared entities begs the question in favor of naturalism while leaving its foundational physical structures as unexplained brute facts.
DOI: 10.17613/w9321-g3z07
Author: Humphrey A. Beña
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236590060
