Anticipatory and Reactive Negotiation Pathways in Irrigation Infrastructure Development: Evidence From 50 Historical Cases in Japan
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The development of agricultural water infrastructure is a critical event in agricultural water management because it can reshape existing water‐use arrangements and may generate competing claims. However, few studies have systematically conceptualised the negotiation processes associated with such infrastructure development. This study develops a process‐oriented model through a qualitative content analysis of 50 cases documented in Japanese administrative reports from the 1960s to the 1980s, documenting negotiations over water management modernisation. The analysis identified two distinct pathways based on their triggering conditions: anticipatory negotiations initiated during project planning in response to expected impacts and reactive negotiations initiated after infrastructure implementation in response to realised impacts. Anticipatory negotiations focused primarily on expected changes and conditions for stakeholder consent, whereas reactive negotiations centred on observed impacts, existing water‐use arrangements and corrective measures. The pathways also differed in the nature of claims, mediation arrangements and negotiated outcomes. These findings indicate that claim emergence, the articulation of concerns about changes in existing water‐use arrangements as stakeholder claims, shapes the content and trajectory of negotiation processes. The framework provides practical guidance for anticipating potential conflicts and supporting conflict prevention and appropriate decision‐making during the planning, construction, modification and renewal of agricultural water infrastructure.
Source: Irrigation and Drainage
DOI: 10.1002/ird.70257
Author: Fuki Yagi
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
Award: G9001399475
OpenAlex ID: W7236595375
