Educational Resource Equity in School Science: Unequal Provision of Materials and Laboratories Across Saudi Arabian Schools, with Limited Evidence That Shortages Widen Achievement Gaps
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Equitable access to science materials, laboratories, and specialist teachers is a precondition for inclusive, socially sustainable education systems, yet unequal provision and demonstrable achievement effects are distinct questions. Using Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) 2023 data for Saudi Arabian Grade 8 students (5882 students in 207 schools, of whom 180 schools entered the school-level models and 5675 students in 200 schools the multilevel models), this study examined whether science resource shortages were unequally distributed and whether they predicted achievement or widened the within-school gradient associated with home educational resources. Weighted school-level regressions related economic disadvantage, language composition, and rurality to four resource conditions; two-level random-slope models tested direct and cross-level moderating associations. Economically disadvantaged and rural schools reported more severe science material-resource shortages and had lower odds of having a laboratory, whereas general and specialist-teacher shortages were not contextually patterned. The material-shortage gradients persisted after adjustment for principals’ general shortage ratings, although the economic gradient was not reproduced with a student-derived socioeconomic measure. No resource condition predicted school-average achievement or moderated the home-resource gradient, including after adjustment for teacher characteristics. The findings substantiate concern about allocation inequities while providing limited evidence that shortages amplify achievement gaps, supporting targeted provision to disadvantaged and rural schools and monitoring of whether resources translate into instructional opportunities.
Source: Sustainability
DOI: 10.3390/su182211798
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,896
Funder: King Saud University
Award: G6971018803
OpenAlex ID: W7236596050
