Work

Self-Reported State Empathy in Response to Video Stimuli: Comparing the Measurement Characteristics of Cognitive and Affective Empathy

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: In this study, we propose an 8-item self-reported state empathy scale comprising four cognitive empathy (CE) and four affective empathy (AE) items to evaluate empathic responses to video stimuli on a per-trial basis and examine its measurement characteristics. For a scale to function as a state measurement, its scores must fluctuate according to the nature of the presented scene, rather than only with stable between-participant differences. Therefore, we had 10 participants repeatedly respond to 24 video stimuli and decomposed the variation in the resulting 240 trials into stimulus effects, participant effects, and residuals. We further conducted correlation analyses using the inclusion of other in the self (IOS) scale and emotion congruence as external criteria for AE and video accuracy rate as an external criterion for CE. In the AE subscale, 42.8% of the variance was attributed to stimulus effects and 8.9% to participant effects, and AE correlated positively with the IOS ( r =.772) and emotion congruence ( r =.308). Conversely, in the CE subscale, the participant effect (33.9%) exceeded the stimulus effect (12.0%), no positive correlation with the video accuracy rate was found, and the CE scores remained high even in incorrect emotion recognition trials. These results suggest that AE captures affective empathic responses that vary with video stimuli, whereas CE, whose internal consistency was low (α=.581), tends to reflect a subjective sense of understanding rather than objective recognition accuracy; the CE results should therefore be interpreted with caution. This study clarified the different measurement characteristics of self-reported CE and AE in state empathy measurement.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236602694
FWCI:
Cites: 34
Cited by:
Related to: 10