Work

When Physical Interaction Becomes Dialogue: Rethinking Communication, Participation, and Community Restoration in Restorative Justice through Japan's WIND BREAKER

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Restorative justice (RJ) places considerable emphasis on dialogue. Yet when dialogue is understood primarily as spoken exchange, the potential of the body as a medium of expression, response, and understanding can be overlooked. Taking the Japanese work WIND BREAKER, first serialized in 2021, as a cultural text, this article examines how bodily confrontation functions in place of spoken dialogue, enabling emotions, lived experiences, and needs for recognition that are difficult to articulate to become intelligible through physical encounters and reciprocal responses. It argues that when the understanding emerging from these encounters receives support from the groups concerned and develops into accountability, the rebuilding of relationships, and the renewal of communal life, the narrative's restorative orientation aligns substantially with RJ's emphasis on community participation and reintegration. Community is understood here both as a network of relationships affected by conflict and as an active participant in witnessing change, supporting acceptance, and sustaining restoration. To extend this argument, the article draws on sign language to demonstrate that dialogue does not require speech and considers international accounts of persons with disabilities participating in restorative processes. These accounts inform an examination of the potential of augmentative and alternative communication tools and artificial intelligence to support autonomous expression. Grounded in conceptual textual interpretation and a discussion of relevant literature, the article neither treats bodily confrontation as evidence of restorative effectiveness in practice nor advocates adopting fighting as an RJ intervention. Whether bodily interaction has restorative significance depends on voluntary and safe participation, opportunities to verify intended meanings, meaningful responses to harm, and the acceptance of responsibility. Group acceptance cannot substitute for the individual wish...
Author: Liu, Yu Wei
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236611746
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10