Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Self-evaluations formed after performance may reflect both external performance evidence and the affective state present when the judgment is made. Yet it remains unclear whether anxiety experienced after consequential performance is associated with calibration beyond anxiety already present beforehand. This prospective observational study included 111 students completing a standardized, summative Objective Structured Clinical Examination. State anxiety was assessed immediately before and after the examination. Retrospective self-evaluations across three competence domains were compared with examiner ratings of the same performance, yielding 333 domain-level observations. Linear mixed-effects models examined the association between post-performance anxiety and signed calibration bias while accounting for pre-performance anxiety, examiner-rated performance, competence domain, and participant-level covariates. Higher post-performance anxiety was associated with more negative calibration (b = − 0.089, 95% cluster-bootstrap confidence interval [− 0.126, − 0.055]), corresponding to an approximately 8.9-percentage-point shift towards self-underestimation per standard-deviation increase in anxiety. The estimate changed little after adjustment for pre-performance anxiety and remained negative in temporal-sensitivity analyses and across all three competence domains. The association was stronger for retrospective self-evaluations than for examiner ratings. Evidence for an association with absolute calibration error was weak, and pre-performance anxiety was not associated with examiner-rated performance. Post-performance anxiety was therefore associated primarily with the direction of self-evaluation relative to external performance evidence, rather than with clearly poorer externally rated performance or greater calibration error irrespective of direction. Because the design was observational, the findings do not establish whether anxiety influenced self-evaluation, resulted from performance appraisal, or reflected unmeasured shared antecedents.
Source: Research Square
Institution: University of Applied Sciences St Pölten
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236614092
