Philosophy of Human–AI Intelligence
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The development of artificial intelligence challenges established philosophical assumptions about the nature of intelligence, the boundaries of cognition, the conditions of knowledge, and the relationship between intelligent performance and conscious experience. Beyond the conventional question of whether machines can think, contemporary human–AI interaction raises a further problem: how should intelligence be understood when cognitive activities are increasingly performed through the interaction of human beings and artificial systems? This paper develops a conceptual framework for the philosophy of human–AI intelligence by integrating perspectives from philosophy of mind, epistemology, extended cognition, distributed cognition, theories of creativity, and the ethics of technology. It distinguishes functional intelligence from epistemic justification, phenomenal consciousness, practical agency, and moral responsibility. On this basis, it examines how human–AI collaboration may generate cognitive outcomes that cannot be adequately explained by treating either the human participant or the artificial system in isolation. The paper introduces an Agency-Preserving Cognitive Synergy Framework, which distinguishes productive augmentation from technological dependency and opaque cognitive amplification. It argues that the philosophical significance of human–AI intelligence lies not exclusively in the performance of artificial systems, but also in their capacity to transform human understanding, creative possibility, intellectual autonomy, and developmental potential. The central thesis is that human–AI cognitive synergy should be evaluated by two interdependent criteria: the expansion of cognitive possibilities and the preservation or development of meaningful human epistemic agency. The proposed framework offers a conceptual foundation for subsequent philosophical analysis and interdisciplinary empirical research.
Author: Shaban, Roman
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: human-AI interaction, human-AI collaboration, extended cognition, distributed cognition, epistemic justification, phenomenal consciousness, practical agency, moral responsibility, creativity, ethics of technology, cognitive synergy, technology dependence, intellectual autonomy, philosophy of mind, epistemology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236621935
