Differential Conformance Testing of Fast Pokémon Battle Simulators Across Generations and Doubles
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Fast battle simulators let a search agent examine more possible actions, but their value depends on the states and outcomes they preserve. We present a measurement case study of differential testing against Pokémon Showdown. The protocol reconstructs positions, checks state conversion, samples reference outcomes for each joint action, and compares them with an enumerating simulator. We reanalyse recorded audits across singles formats and doubles, separating discrete-outcome agreement, modal agreement, damage-roll identity, and converter acceptance. In Gen 9 Ubers, strict deterministic agreement rose from 95.84% to 98.32% on development sample A and from 99.24% to 99.82% on re-drawn sample B after reference-setup repairs. The engine with 17 patches scored 98.32% on its debugging sample and 93.31% on a re-drawn sample, but a changed state interface confounds that contrast. In doubles, the final development run reached 98.77% strict agreement and 97.79% damage-roll identity; the originally planned gate was not met. A later statistical criterion gave 99.95% on development run 4. On 600 sealed fresh doubles positions, strict agreement was 98.23% and damage-roll identity was 98.02%; both original gates remained unmet. A sealed follow-up sampled 5,400 decisions from new recorded singles games and public doubles replays and completed 9 format comparisons with the deployed engines frozen. Strict deterministic agreement ranged from 97.92% to 99.58%. The format-level results include conversion refusals, pair exclusions, and position-clustered intervals. The sealed results measure installed simulators with frozen reconstruction and comparison code on new games. The historical repair samples remain development evidence, not independent tests.
Author: Mamun, S M Abdulla Al
Institution: University of Manchester
Language: English
Subfield: Software
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: differential testing, state reconstruction
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236635053
