How Accurate Are Open-Source Social Security Calculators?
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: People use open-source calculators to estimate their Social Security retirement benefit, and no study we know of checks them against an exact answer. We built the Social Security Administration's published calculator, ran 1,231 synthetic (made-up) workers through it, many on the edges of the rules, and used its results as the answer key. A second program, written from the law, agrees on every worker. Of five calculators, one matches the agency for every worker. Three give a wrong monthly benefit for 2, 15 and 19 percent of workers, mostly through three small mistakes. Two round to the nearest cent before rounding down, making some benefits a dollar too high. Two miss that the law counts someone born on 1 January as born the year before, worth up to 175 dollars a month. One ignores the yearly limit on countable earnings, putting a high earner typically 597 dollars a month too high. An ordinary worker, born mid-month and earning under the limit, gets the right amount or a dollar more. The fifth counts only earnings from age 22 to 61, as its code states, and runs a little low. Why were the mistakes not caught? Developers test against published worked examples, and three, in a Congressional Research Service report and the federal regulations, print an amount the rules do not give. Checks written without an answer key caught the two largest mistakes and missed the rounding one. We release the workers, official answers and checks so anyone can test a calculator this way.
Author: Thapa, Shirshak Jung
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236635658
