Work

Beyond Gender and Ethnicity: Intersectional Disadvantages in Perceptions of Job Suitability and Pay

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article examines how the intersection of gender and ethnicity shapes public perceptions of appropriate pay and job suitability in Italy. Drawing on intersectional status theory, we investigate whether immigrant women face a compounded disadvantage compared to immigrant men and native Italian women and men. We also explore whether these evaluations vary across population subgroups. We use a factorial survey experiment administered to 2,000 respondents in February 2025, in which candidates' gender and ethnic background are experimentally varied across three high-status occupations. The findings reveal a divergence between evaluations of appropriate pay and job suitability. While no substantial differences emerge in perceived appropriate salaries across candidate groups, gender and ethnicity significantly shape assessments of job suitability. In particular, Latin American women experience a compounded disadvantage, receiving lower suitability evaluations than their counterparts, whereas Middle Eastern/Central Asian women face an ethnic penalty comparable to that experienced by men from the same backgrounds. These patterns suggest that intersectional disadvantages are not uniform across ethnic groups. Furthermore, suitability penalties are particularly pronounced among male respondents and residents of Central Italy. Overall, the findings highlight how culturally shared status beliefs surrounding gender and ethnicity shape public evaluations of labour market candidates, potentially contributing to the legitimation and reproduction of existing inequalities.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236640280
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10