Work

Extinction accounts: Neanderthals (Homo neanderthalensis)

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Neanderthal extinction remains one of the most intensively debated episodes in human evolution. This review synthesises current evidence to examine not simply why Neanderthals disappeared, but how extinction unfolded across Europe. The emerging picture does not support explanations based on a single physiological, behavioural, or cognitive disadvantage. Neanderthals were ecologically flexible and culturally complex, while genomic evidence reveals a spatially heterogeneous demographic history: some populations were small and isolated, others remained regionally connected, and many experienced repeated contraction, turnover, and re-expansion. Their disappearance likewise unfolded as a regional mosaic rather than a synchronous continental event. During the Late Pleistocene, climatic instability altered resource availability, habitat suitability, and the geographic ranges of mammalian communities, contributing to broader ecological reorganisation. At the same time, the expansion of H. sapiens introduced new ecological, demographic, cultural, and genetic interactions into an already reorganising system. Although the specific mechanisms through which these factors operated remain unresolved, Neanderthal extinction is best understood as a historically contingent sequence of regional demographic declines in which environmental change, population connectivity and stochasticity altered the balance between cycles of population contraction and re-expansion. Therefore, the central challenge is not identifying a dominant cause, but determining when, where, and under which conditions interacting pressures crossed the threshold from population decline to irreversible regional extinction. Addressing this question is complicated by equifinality and by mismatched temporal scales between archaeological, palaeoclimatic, and genetic records. Future research should derive explicit, testable archaeological expectations for competing extinction mechanisms and develop analytical approaches capable of distinguishing among them without relying primarily on chronological correlation. Such approaches are essential for moving from plausible extinction scenarios to testing how Neanderthal extinction actually unfolded.
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236644177
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10