Work

Why We Should Stop Using the Term Gendered Family Violence

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: I support ending the use of gendered family violence as the organising description of family violence. Gendered theories and population patterns can inform research and prevention. They cannot by themselves establish who used violence, who experienced it, or why it occurred in an individual family. This analysis examines how gendered framing operates through service eligibility, referral pathways and the ordering of competing inquiries. In Australia, the State of Victoria’s Orange Door and Multi-Agency Risk Assessment and Management (MARAM) materials document differences in service access and assessment pathways. Family Justice Council guidance in England and Wales gives domestic-abuse inquiries priority when considering allegations of alienating behaviour. These jurisdictions and arrangements differ: Victoria provides explicit gender-differentiated pathways; the Family Justice Council guidance prioritises domestic-abuse inquiries, whose relationship to gendered framing requires separate examination. The evidence examined raises questions about whether possible victimisation and perpetration receive equivalent scrutiny across genders. It does not establish the accuracy of every classification or reassessment. Transparent criteria and independent evaluation are needed. The analysis also questions whether the gendered framework adequately accounts for the available research, or gives supportive evidence greater standing than findings that challenge its organising assumptions. Research documents violence in more than one direction, including parental alienating behaviours affecting mothers and fathers. Assessment must examine conduct, context, effects and risk, while distinguishing protective responses from abusive conduct. Removing gendered from the organising description would leave gender-related explanations available wherever supported by evidence. Assessment standards, service pathways, and error correction must also be accountable to that evidence.
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236647419
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10