Work

DanielNaurin, UrškaŠadl and JanZglinski, Empirical Legal Studies in EU Law, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2026, hb, 436pp, £115.00

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Politics of European Legal Research: Behind the Method (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2022); Rossana Deplano and others (eds), Interdisciplinary Research Methods in EU Law: A Handbook (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2024), as well as the many articles in specialist EU law journals cited therein.The new instalment of that strand of literature is the volume under review.Even though the chapters contained therein cover many topics and thus speak to various literatures, the introduction frames it as a book on method (1) and this will be the main focus here.This review will first give a sense of the structure and purpose of the book.It will then show how the main themes play out in selected chapters, before moving on to discuss an objection that has been moved against empirical studies in general, namely their excessive ambition.The volume addresses very varied questions across 20 chapters, divided into three parts (foundations, data and methods, and themes).Many of the chapters present original research based on primary sources.The purpose of the volume, announced in the introduction as 'to get an overview of the state of the art [and] showcasing the need for and potential of this new field of academic inquiry' (1), is articulated by Zglinksi's chapter.It explains that empirical legal studies add to the methods with which we study EU law (26) but also to the questions we ask (29) and, more generally, that they expand the object of inquiry of EU legal scholarship (31).Concrete examples are found in the book: we answer old questions with new methods, as do the chapters by López Xurita and Sindbjerg Martinsen on the policy impact of the Court of Justice of the EU); we also answer new questions with new methods -as in the chapter by Sevuru on judicial behaviour at the Court of Justice of the EU; and we ask questions about something new, as witnessed by the literature on non-institutional actors -exemplified in the book by the chapter by Hermansen and Pavone on who litigates and who influences judges.The introduction also says that empirical legal studies 'should focus on testing hypotheses that are connected to general theories about law and legal change' (12).The first part of this statement, the focus on testing hypotheses, is fundamental as it is one way to counter the objections to empirical studies
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7236648999
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10