An effect-algebraic framework for mediative truth-falsity semantics in quantum evidence models
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Quantum evidence models may involve positive and negative support for a proposition that are not naturally represented as complementary events. This paper develops an effect-algebraic framework for mediative truth–falsity semantics in quantum evidence models with generally non-complementary effects. For each proposition, positive and negative evidence are represented by two possibly noncommuting quantum effects on a finite-dimensional Hilbert space and evaluated on a density operator through Born expectations. The resulting Born degrees define a two-coordinate truth–falsity pair, from which state-dependent hesitation and contradiction degrees are obtained. A state-dependent mediative effect is then constructed as a convex combination of the positive evidence effect and the complement of the negative evidence effect. The main results show that this mediative operator is always a valid quantum effect and that its Born expectation exactly recovers the corresponding classical mediative score. This establishes a parallel Born reading with exact classical reduction. Within the class of continuous convex-segment lifts depending on the Born pair, exact classical reduction uniquely determines the mixing coefficient. A positive-first sequential Lüders reading evaluates negative evidence after the non-selective update induced by the positive channel. Its disturbance witness vanishes for every state when the effects commute; for projective positive evidence, universal zero disturbance is equivalent to commutativity, and the witness sign determines the positive-first/parallel score ordering. An unsharp-qubit extension evaluates both measurement orders and retains separate directional witnesses; their signed symmetric summary can vanish by cancellation, while the negative-first score relation requires direct analysis because the scalar score is not globally monotone in positive support. A diagonal embedding recovers every classical truth–falsity pair as a special case. A short diagonal metadata illustration is included only to demonstrate semantic instantiation outside the purely symbolic examples. The construction does not claim a quantum circuit, computational speedup, or empirical superiority.
Source: Physica Scripta
Author: Oscar Humberto Montiel Ross
Institution: Instituto Politécnico Nacional
Language: English
Topic: Advanced Algebra and Logic
Subfield: Computational Theory and Mathematics
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: effect algebras, Lüders rule, density matrix
Open Access status: bronze
Funder: Instituto Politécnico Nacional
OpenAlex ID: W7236649515
