A State Within the Program: Computational Efficiency, Emergence, and Collective Consciousness in a Simulated Universe
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Most discussion of the simulation hypothesis asks whether we are in a simulation. This paper asks a rather different question: if we were in a simulation, what features of the program might we be able to see from the inside? From a computer science perspective, I argue that the universe shows features that are very much in the spirit of computational efficiency. Quantum systems remain in a state of probability until an interaction forces a definite state, which is analogous to lazy evaluation and selective rendering in software. Complex structures of all kinds, such as Fibonacci spirals in plants, DNA and galaxies, can be generated from very simple rules applied over and over again, which is the essence of procedural generation. There is also a limit to how fast information can travel and how far it can reach, marked by the horizon of the observable universe. This is an argument from analogy rather than a proof, and I respond to the main objections, including the recent claim by Faizal et al. (2025) that the universe cannot be simulated. I then turn to a question that the simulation debate rarely addresses: what is the point of it? Building on the idea of cosmopsychism, I suggest that the point of the universe might be to provide a medium in which a collective consciousness can develop, learning from the many different experiences of the individual lives it contains, just as an AI model learns from the many different data points it is given. I conclude that whether or not the universe is a program, our experiences are real to us.
Institution: University of Southampton
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236656650
