When fieldwork becomes suspicious: ‘Precarious ethnography,’ state surveillance, and the conditions of student fieldwork in the Philippines
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Ethnographic fieldwork remains central to understanding the fragmented and uneven realities of an archipelagic Philippines. But what happens when the relational conditions of fieldwork themselves become objects of political suspicion and surveillance? Drawing on a retrospective analysis of a 2023 undergraduate anthropology field school in a Philippine island municipality, this paper proposes precarious ethnography as a conceptual orientation and methodological condition for inquiry under political uncertainty. Bringing Agamben’s (2005) ‘state of exception’ into dialogue with Butler’s (2004, 2009) account of relational exposure, it examines how politically produced uncertainty reshapes the ethnographic encounter and the co-production of knowledge. Precarious ethnography is articulated through four interconnected dimensions: politically produced, relational, epistemological, and anticipatory. In resonance with Haraway’s (2016) call to “stay with the trouble,” the paper argues for an ethics of answerability to the consequences that ethnographic ways of knowing may impose on those whose lives and relationships make anthropological knowledge possible.
Source: Ethnography
Author: Emmanuel Reed Horton Viceral
Institution: Ateneo de Manila University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7236658499
