One mine, two maps: label conventions change which satellite segmentation model wins, and a convention-conditioned network serves both
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Public inventories of mining land disagree about where a mine ends. The two global polygon sets most often used to train satellite models follow different delineation conventions: Maus et al. (2022) enclose the land between mine features, and Tang and Werner (2023) trace each feature. We ask what this difference does to learning and to evaluation, and whether one model can serve both conventions. On 722 Sentinel-2 tiles that carry both label sets, the two conventions overlap at a median IoU of 0.655, and the Tang area is 78% of the Maus area. A U-Net trained on one convention loses when it is scored on the other, and the ranking of the two single-convention models reverses with the reference: +0.062 IoU for the Maus-trained model on Maus labels and −0.027 on Tang labels (five seeds; both intervals exclude zero). We then test a remedy that was specified before the runs. A single network receives the requested convention, either as a second output channel or through feature-wise modulation. On 113 tiles that no model had seen and that were used for no design choice, the conditioned model beats an unconditioned model trained on the same mixed labels (+0.031 IoU), stays within the pre-specified margin of −0.02 against the single-convention model (−0.004), and its matching output beats its other output (+0.075). Its predicted area is within 6% of the label area in each convention, where the unconditioned model is 11% low or 17% high. The gain was detectable on the 86 Maus-only tiles. On the 27 Tang-only tiles the interval included zero. An exploratory zone analysis suggests why: the network uses the convention as an inclusiveness setting, not as a second object definition. Under a score that ignores disputed pixels, the ranking reversal is not detected. We close with reporting recommendations for mining benchmarks. Third-party material retains the licences identified in the manuscript.
Author: Mamun, S M Abdulla Al
Institution: University of Manchester
Language: English
Subfield: Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: mining area mapping, Sentinel-2, U-Net, benchmarking
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236698104
